INTRODUCTION
Hello, and welcome to The Monster & The Child, where childhood studies and monster studies collide! I am Dr. Kathleen Kellett, and today I am talking about Philip Pullman’s His Dark Materials, which I can’t believe I haven’t done on this channel yet. This trilogy was the subject of my Master’s thesis, which was … pretty far back in the day at this point … and I also actually have two published papers about it. So I think it’s high time that I bring my long-standing interest in these books, and particularly their monsters, over here.
So this video is going to be a version of my first ever published paper, which was called, “Beyond the Collapse of Meaning: Narratives of Monstrosity in Philip Pullman’s His Dark Materials.” It was published by University of Toronto Quarterly in 2017. This was for a special edition on monstrosity, naturally, and this paper was adapted from my earlier and much longer thesis. Now, YouTube video essays and journal articles are not the same genre of writing, but for some reason I thought that adapting and reworking the paper for this medium would be easy and straightforward. It was not. So I do want to say upfront that this one is a bit different from my usual fare here. Typically on this channel, I’m doing media analysis that is very grounded in childhood studies theory and teaching. I see the way I write for YouTube as a cross between a conference paper and a classroom lecture, leaning more towards the latter, because while I do make arguments, it’s generally with an aim of communicating core concepts in childhood studies, such as how to recognize and critique social constructions of childhood in media, etc. But this paper was originally written before I even joined the Childhood Studies department at Rutgers; my Masters was in Children’s Literature. So this was a literature paper, grounded in literary theories and analysis – so not only a different genre of writing than what I do over here, but also a whole different theoretical approach. So what I’ve wound up doing is keeping the basics of my original arguments while also injecting some of the childhood studies stuff that I’ve been working with for the decade since I wrote this. I think I’ve produced something generally coherent, but there will be more sort of Academic-with-a-capital-A literary theory in this one. If you are down for that, then I hope you will enjoy this little foray into my scholarly past.
Before we get to that, though, just a reminder that if you want more monster education and community in your life, I have programs that you can enroll in on themonsterandthechild.com. I run a Monster Book Club for adults that meets on the last Wednesday of each month, although that might be a little different for November, because of Thanksgiving, but typically; and the book that we will be discussing this month is N.D. Stevenson’s Nimona, a personal favorite of mine. If you are or know a teenager who’d be interested in something similar, then check out the teen Monster Book Club, too – and also take a look at Youth Monsterology, a five-month teen lit group and educational mentorship program that I am hoping to start in the spring. I also have a Patreon, where patrons get monthly monster story reaction videos and polls for future video topics. These links are down in the description, and I would love to see you in one of these communities!
All right, so back to His Dark Materials. Today, I will be talking entirely about the books. I cannot talk about the movie adaptation because, based on all advice I’ve ever received, I haven’t watched it. I have seen the HBO series adaptation from a few years ago, which I thought overall was, like, mid to fine, but I will say the performances are very good, especially Ruth Wilson as Mrs. Coulter. I honestly think it’s worth watching that whole show just for her. In this paper, I don’t talk that much about Mrs. Coulter – perhaps in a future video, I might – but know that she is a very meaty character, and Ruth Wilson nails every single nuance. She is scary, hateful, heartbreaking, enraged, wronged, lonely, petulant, brilliant – she’s just everything. So while these books are honestly inherently difficult to translate for the screen, I think, I am glad that we get an all-time great performance based on them.
But like I said, this video is going to be all about the books. The images that I will use are a combination of official illustrations by either Peter Bailey or Chris Wormell, as well as a few images from the TV show, just as visual aids. In this trilogy, consisting of The Golden Compass or Northern Lights, depending on your country, and then The Subtle Knife, and The Amber Spyglass, Philip Pullman tells the story of Lyra Belacqua, a.k.a. my most beautiful daughter, who is a young girl first on the edge of and then eventually in the throes of puberty. She lives in an alternate Earth, where England (and, it’s implied, pretty much the entire globe) is controlled by the Church. This Church is a worst-of-all-worlds mix of Catholic and Calvinist theology, due to history shaking out differently over in this universe, and it primarily refers to God as “the Authority,” which gives you an idea of the vibe. Like our own Christian churches, this is an institution governed by narratives: specifically, Biblical narratives. These stories create and police the boundaries of acceptable expressions of human subjectivity, of personhood. They also mandate the expulsion, or abjection, of those whose knowledge and experience stray outside of those boundaries. Scientific and moral self-knowledge, and especially sexual awakenings, are considered utterly sinful.
This poses a bit of a problem for the inhabitants of this world, because all of those things occur naturally when the capital-D Dust, the eponymous dark material – which is eventually revealed to be the elemental particle of consciousness – gathers around and clings to humans, a process that is occurs during adolescence (and specifically, physical puberty). Death, too, is obscured and denied in the Church. Since no one can actually avoid either growing up or dying, that means everyone eventually becomes an outcast in the Authority’s narratives and therefore abjected from his order – which, considering the power he wields, has extremely bad consequences for us poor mortals.
Yet his is not the only story that exists. A counternarrative, a prophecy about a new Eve, destined to bring about a second “Fall of Man,” has arisen. Of course, according to the Authority and his followers, such a figure would be a monster: a destroyer of order and boundaries. But to some people telling the story, this new Eve is the protagonist, not the antagonist. And, indeed, she is the protagonist of this series, Lyra. So she and the Authority both serve dual roles: protagonists of their own narratives, antagonists of each other’s.
You have probably heard me say before that one of the main definitions that I use for monstrosity is the antagonistic opposite of humanity. The monster breaks the rules of what it means to be human, so much so that it cannot be considered part of that category. But it’s not just like an animal, which is not human but in a culturally nonthreatening way. Rather, the monster attacks the behavioral, moral, and geographic boundaries that hold humanity together. The thing about this definition is that it means monsters can’t exist in the abstract. They require someone to a) make the rules of humanity and b) identify when someone breaks them and call attention to that danger. In other words, monsters require a narrator. They are beings of story, and their stories have a specific shape: monster-antagonist attacks humanity, and often, hero-protagonist defends it.
The Authority, as his name implies, is an author, and his narratives are authoritative. So when he and his Church are the narrators, then acceptable humanity is defined by its obedience and its willingness to exist only within the spaces that the Authority has carved out for his subjects, and anyone who would disobey and would break through those boundaries would be considered a monster. So those are one set of narratives that exist within the world of the text. But of course, the text itself is a narrative, with a narrator, one Philip Pullman, who really, really hates God. These three novels, therefore, narrate a version of humanity defined by its capacity to learn freely and pursue science and relationships without censure. Anyone who would violate those freedoms is a monster in this narrative. So that’s the central idea I’m working with here: Lyra and the Authority are dueling monsters in each other’s stories. Though neither of them are “traditional” monsters, like vampires or werewolves, both of them can be understood within this narrative framework of a monster story. Analyzing them in that way allows us to analyze the themes and assumptions the text itself makes about humanity.
So let’s dive into Lyra’s story, in which she accepts sin, falls in love, and opens herself up to all the dead and outcast of the infinite worlds of the multiverse – and does it all while she is still, crucially, an adolescent.
DUST AND DÆMONS: THE ORIGINS OF NARRATIVES
For anyone unfamiliar with His Dark Materials, the first thing you should know is that, even though the Church situation is quite bad, there is a major benefit to being lucky enough to be born into Lyra’s parallel universe. Of all the countless worlds, this one is the only one where humans have external souls that appear as personal animal companions called “dæmons” – that is, d-a and e squished together-m-o-n. Prepubescent children’s dæmons change form frequently, but during adolescence, the dæmon “settles” on a permanent form (Pullman Compass 167). (Pause here to determine what your dæmon would be. Mine is a flying fox.) It is excruciatingly painful for humans and dæmons to be separated from one another, and to touch another person’s dæmon is completely taboo, with pretty overtly sexual connotations.
In this world, Lyra is an orphan (or so she believes) being raised by the various faculty and staff of Jordan College, one of the institutions within the larger Oxford University. (The former only exists in Lyra’s world, though obviously our world shares the latter.) Without any one authority figure that she has to regularly answer to, she and her dæmon, Pantalaimon, or “Pan” for short, are a free-roaming double entity. Pantalaimon means all-merciful or all-compassionate, and then Pan obviously just means all or everything, and honestly, that’s just a distillation of Lyra’s entire arc, as befits her literal soul. Lyra enjoys disobeying rules, running amok and playing somewhat violent games with the working-class children of Oxford, including her best friend, the kitchen boy, Roger. She is in no rush for Pan to settle; she loves him fiercely, and she loves that he can become whatever they both desire. Their bond, at the beginning, is an unquestioned and uncomplicatedly positive fact of life.
Not so for the rest of her society. Dæmons, it turns out, are the conduit the mysterious element called Dust. When dæmons settle, Dust gathers and clings to adolescents – or, to hear the Church tell it, the young people’s “dæmons are infected with Dust” (282-283). Upon the fairly recent discovery of the empirical existence of Dust – it is invisible to the naked eye, but can be photographed with special lenses – it was given its name after the Biblical quote “for Dust thou art and to Dust thou shalt return.” In this world’s version of Genesis, the settling of dæmons is part of God’s punishment for Adam and Eve’s sin. Therefore, when Dust is discovered to coincide with this settling, the logical conclusion is that Dust is sin itself, the ultimate monster.
However, this narrative is at odds with the scientific laws and truths of this and, indeed, every universe. Dust is actually “what happens when matter begins to understand itself” (Pullman Spyglass 31). It is just matter, so it is not created or destroyed, but curiosity catalyzes an elemental transubstantiation. What was non-conscious becomes consciousness itself. In other words, Dust is subjectivity. When Dust begins to structure its understanding into communicable frameworks, it becomes the origin of the first narratives, and the order of language itself. So here’s where we get into some of the theories I used in my time analyzing this series, starting with Mikhail Bakhtin. In his essay “Discourse in the Novel,” he uses a term called “heteroglossia,” which he defines as “forms for conceptualizing the world in words, specific world views, each characterized by its own objects, meanings and values” (494). In other words, even within a single language, like English or Russian, in Bakhtin’s case, there are multiple levels of language – not just dialect, though that is part of it – but registers of formality, of familiarity, of implicit ideologies and value systems. The novel, Bakhtin argues, is an art form in which heteroglossia can and must exist, because it contains the language of the narrator, and then also of various characters, and of competing narratives within the overarching whole. A lot of the meaning that derives from a novel, therefore, is in the way that these “languages” interact.
So in His Dark Materials, some of these high-formality, culturally authoritative languages are derived from the Bible, Milton’s Paradise Lost, and classical mythology, whose narratives Pullman subverts and reinvents. (Indeed, the phrase “his dark materials” comes from Book II of Paradise Lost.) But, by the way he establishes Dust, Pullman also embeds a multiplicity of languages, of narratives, within every single character within the trilogy, because each particle of Dust represents an individual point of view, and each conscious being contains many, many particles of Dust. Therefore, people in His Dark Materials are inherently heteroglossic in and of themselves. Everyone contains multiple perspectives, multiple meanings – and everyone, by nature, defies the constriction of a single master narrative imposed from above.
Not for lack of trying on the part of the master narrative, of course. The Church would like very much to cut off the expansive meaning-making ability of consciousness at the source. Enter Mrs. Coulter. This character is introduced as a tantalizingly beautiful woman with a golden monkey for a dæmon, who lures vulnerable, marginalized children away to their doom. She also happens to be Lyra’s mother, though Lyra herself does not know this at first. Lyra was born of an affair between the young married Mrs. Coulter and the aristocrat and scientific explorer, Lord Asriel. Lyra believes the latter to be her uncle, but when she first encounters Mrs. Coulter in The Golden Compass, she is simply an enchanting stranger. Mrs. Coulter uses her feminine charm and glamor to lead the Church’s General Oblation Board. The kids of Oxford call the mysterious people taking children “Gobblers,” which is both a play on “General Oblation Board,” GOB, as well as a clear bogeyman-style monster story that evokes the taboo of cannibalism. And Mrs. Coulter is that monster. She kidnaps Lyra’s friend Roger, and Lyra’s subsequent quest to rescue him takes her to the far North of her world, and comprises the plot of the first book.
The purpose of the General Oblation Board is to sever the connection between children and their dæmons with a procedure called “intercision” before Dust settles upon them at puberty. The idea is that the children would then remain sinless and innocent their whole lives, with the dæmon simply serving as a “beloved pet” as opposed to part of the same entity. This process has kind of worked for some adults, though of course, the Dust has already come to them, so while intercision may mitigate their “sin,” it doesn’t prevent it entirely. Unfortunately, the process for kids has thus far only yielded the total destruction of the psyche and then, shortly thereafter, death. If you think that would deter the Church, then you haven’t quite figured out Pullman’s feelings about organized religion yet.
The whole effort to circumvent Dust and therefore sin is ultimately a farce. The Authority, God himself, is eventually revealed to not, in fact, be the Creator as he claims. He is simply the first angel, which here is a name for a being of condensed Dust (Pullman Spyglass 32). He represents the first time multiple particles of consciousness clung together to form a larger mind. Therefore, the master narrative – his master narrative – that seeks to replace each individual’s multiplicity of meanings with one single capital-T Truth, is explicitly a lie. The Authority’s deception is twofold: first, he claims to be superior to all other consciousness, and second, he claims that his own individual subjectivity is everlasting. In other words, he says that he is immune to death. These lies become the foundation of the Authority’s hierarchical system of authorized expressions of subjectivity – a.k.a. the culture of the Church – which is directly at odds with not only everyone else’s but also the Authority’s own nature as knowledge-seeking Dust. The Authority knows that if other subjects become fully self-aware, they will realize that there is no fundamental difference between their consciousness and his. Therefore, under his rule, nature and knowledge are anathema, and those who would seek either face harsh censure. Since, in Pullman’s version of “nature,” human subjectivity undergoes the greatest alteration and expansion during adolescence (when Dust settles) and after death (when the subject’s conscious matter, including their temporarily condensed Dust, disperses), that means adolescents and the dead are the subjects who must be most tightly controlled by the Authority. We therefore have intercision for adolescents, and, as we’ll see in a bit, imprisonment for the dead.
But as powerful as the Authority is, it’s pretty hard to control beings composed of the literal physical essence of knowledge-seeking and curiosity. Other angels form after the Authority. In his hierarchy, they are ranked as superior to organic animals – they are physical matter, but not biological, since they are only Dust, instead of meat plus Dust, like humans are. However, they’re still ranked below the Authority himself. When some angels realize that they are not the Authority’s creations and are, in fact, literally the same thing as him, they rebel by granting consciousness to humanity (and the other conscious animals of the multiverse) (Pullman Knife 249-250). So Pullman rewrites the story of the “fallen angels,” Satan and his minions revolting against God, as the actual source of human knowledge.
In “Circumventing the Grand Narrative: Dust as an Alternate Theological Vision in Pullman’s His Dark Materials,” Anne-Marie Bird describes Dust as “an ambiguous, almost mystical presence in which everything coexists” that represents “a rejection of the idea of division and separation as a means of making sense of the world” (190-191). Bird doesn’t think that this concept really works the way Pullman entirely wants it to. Pullman sets up the Authority as a monstrous oppressor because his “totalizing discourses can be sustained only by the evils of repressing or excluding what does not fit” (194). But Dust is, in Bird’s mind, also a totalizing discourse, because it represents all of nature and science, which are Pullman’s capital-T Truths. I think she has a real point here, and I’ll get into some of my critiques of Pullman’s vision of Dust later on. But I do think that Dust does (or at least can) represent a different kind of approach to “truth” due to its inherent heteroglossia. Pullman himself can be – let’s go with dogmatic – but he did invent something here that can be interpreted by readers such as myself as a resistance to dogma, because Dust incorporates all narratives, all perspectives. The individual particles don’t have to agree with one another, even when condensed within the same form. I find this exciting.
With that said, the rebel angels’ revenge does reduce the origin of human consciousness to an act of aggression. It was more about sticking it to God than it was about spreading knowledge. I’m not sure if Pullman himself sees this as an issue, because he also really wants to stick it to God, but as a human myself, if I were in this multiverse and learned that history, I’d be kind of bummed about it. It makes humanity a pawn, a thing to be manipulated. But the way Lyra plays out the story of the second Fall takes us in a new and, to my mind, better direction. The expansion of her consciousness is fueled by empathy with the outcast and even with her enemies, and she therefore rejects the divisiveness of both the Authority and the original rebel angels. But to do this, she must become one of the prime monsters of the Authority’s culture: Eve.
THE AUTHORITY AND EVE: THE ORIGIN OF MONSTERS
Towards the end of The Golden Compass, Lord Asriel reads Lyra a passage from Genesis, which in their world is written as follows:
But when the man and the woman knew their own dæmons, they knew that a great change had come upon them, for until that moment it had seemed that they were at one with all the creatures of the earth and the air, and there was no difference between them:
And they saw the difference, and they knew good and evil; and they were ashamed, and they sewed fig leaves together to cover their nakedness. (Pullman Compass 372)
Lord Asriel explains that, in the Church, this moment of recognizing the difference between the self and the rest of nature was the source of “sin and shame and death” (372). Yet differentiating between self and not-self is considered one of the very first stages of childhood development, especially within psychoanalytic theories. In “Approaching Abjection,” Julia Kristeva explains that the opposition between subject and object “settles [the subject] within the fragile texture of a desire for meaning” (1-2). It’s the basics of how we make sense of our place within our physical and cultural surroundings. Yet to the Church, the “desire for meaning” at all is sin.
It makes sense, then, that the first emotion that Eve and Adam experience after their new understanding is shame. As soon as they become aware of their difference from one another, as gendered and sexual beings, they cover their naked bodies. Thus the first moment of human subjectivity is also a moment of encountering the abject. If you haven’t watched one of my videos where I talk about abjection or you just need a refresher, Kristeva defines the abject as that which is “neither subject nor object,” yet that “has only one quality of the object — that of being opposed to I” (1). In other words, the abject isn’t as cleanly separate from the self as, like, this microphone, where our definitions and boundaries and substance are completely and clearly different. That’s subject vs. object. Instead, the abject is both inherently a part of and interior to human existence and utterly threatening to the creation of a stable sense of self within that existence. It’s everything we’re not supposed to contain or be, that we don’t want to acknowledge as part of our individual subjectivity. This can encompass physical substances, like waste or other bodily fluids, when they are not safely hidden and contained. And I mean, it is pretty literally threatening to subjectivity if you are, for example, bleeding out. That stuff has to stay inside its vascular borders if you want to go on having a stable consciousness! But it’s not just about the literal: the abject is also the culturally unacceptable. In cultures where the human body is meant to be seen as a controlled, contained vessel for the soul, leaking fluids all over the place isn’t just physically unpleasant, it’s also shameful and scary. It threatens to turn you from a respectably enculturated subject to just meat and parts. The abject threatens dis-integration of the self. So beyond the physical substances of the abject, we can also add things like violent urges or taboo sexuality or the acknowledgement of that ultimate disintegration: mortality and death.
However, the abject is not only something that we shove away. Kristeva explains that even as it repulses us, the abject seductively pulls seemingly stable subjects “toward the place where meaning collapses” (2). So it can’t be surprising that abjection and monstrosity have a strong established relationship. Monsters frequently, if not always, in some way, embody abjection and, in doing so, expose the gaps in incomplete systems of meaning, as our pal Jeffrey Jerome Cohen argues in “Monster Culture: Seven Theses.” Monsters “are disturbing hybrids whose externally incoherent bodies resist attempts to fit them into any systematic structuration,” a definition that definitely applies to the heteroglossic Dust (6). The Authority would sure like to fit all consciousness into a hierarchy (with himself at the top), but when every individual is actually a hybrid amalgam of uncountable perspectives and meanings – and then you add organic sexual bodies on top of that – it becomes very hard to do so.
Cohen argues that as “a construct and a projection, the monster exists only to be read” (4). But I think that monsters are not simply narrated; they can also be narrators. They are the abject with a point of view and with agency of their own. Paradoxically, they’re abjection as subjectivity, the I within the not-I. If the monster tells its own story, then the listener must either reject it to remain “safe,” or be annihilated or fundamentally changed to such a degree that the listener also becomes a monster. Think about it: in a monster story, the victim either dies or turns. The monster is the agent that causes that action. It is the abject made into an active, purposeful force.
Since one of the options of a monstrous outcome is death, most monsters have something to do with mortality, and that is extremely true in His Dark Materials. Without unnatural intervention, all physical things die, including angels. Their particles dissipate, and the temporary individual consciousness falls apart. The Authority is extremely not into this idea. Now, he can’t prevent all of the outcomes of death. Human bodies, for example, are beyond his purview to preserve, as are their souls. Dæmons evaporate at the moment life ends. But Pullman’s humans have three parts: the body, the soul, and the spirit. This third substance, which also includes Dust (and possibly other particles? Frankly unclear, but just kind of bear with me) – this is what the Authority imprisons as ghosts in the world of the dead. He preserves them, but he also abjects them – he hides them away between universes so they can’t escape back into nature. Even though these spirits aren’t literally bodies, they function as corpses to the Authority. They are made of physical matter and they remind him that, despite all his self-written narratives, his own individual subjectivity is also ultimately finite. In “Semiotics of Biblical Abomination,” Kristeva explains that, in Biblical texts, the corpse is “the opposite of the spiritual, of the symbolic, and of divine law” (109). Corpses are ritually unclean and must be set apart from the practice of worship. Giant caveat: the meaning of ritual impurity or uncleanliness is historically and culturally situated, and the interpretations of that state that occur over many, many centuries since the original writings obviously have gone through many, many different meanings. But the one that Pullman is interested in is the interpretation that death is a result of sin, and that God can and will eventually triumph over death. Until that point, however, death is a reminder of our fundamental difference from the perfection of the divine. Pullman, I think fairly, finds that notion psychologically unhealthy for mortal people such as ourselves.
Those who follow the Authority in life do not yet know that they will be his imprisoned victims in death. Because of the stories he has created, where he is the protagonist who fights monsters, they don’t recognize him as a monstrous figure himself, one who will violate their personhood. Instead, Eve is “the scapegoated monster,” a figure who Cohen explains is “ritually destroyed in the course of some official narrative, purging the community by eliminating its sins” (18). As the Mother of All, Eve takes the blame, passing her sin and its mortal consequence to all of humanity. Anyone too like Eve – disobedient, sexual, or knowledge-seeking – faces abjection, like Eve’s expulsion from Eden.
As the prophesied new Eve, Lyra will fulfill the same narrative requirements as her predecessor in Genesis: through her transgressions against the Authority, she will be responsible for the life and death of all humanity. The in-world narrative of her monstrosity and the overarching text’s narrative of the Authority’s differ in both substance and structure. In “The Monster’s Sacrifice — Historic Time,” K.A. Nuzum argues that monsters exist in either mythic or liminal time. Mythic time is circular, providing a narrative structure in which “monsters perform their own rituals re-enacting the moment of their creation” (Nuzum 209). These mythic narratives hinge upon the repetition of a single action, and Nuzum provides an example of a vampire sucking blood, just as its blood was once sucked (209-210). The Authority’s narrative definitely takes place within mythic time. He continually performs his own name, his own self-granted identity. He authors his narrative in which he is triumphant over death, he authorizes the forms of subjectivity for his literal subjects that he deems appropriate, and then he abjects the ways of being that do not fit within his lines, beginning with Eve’s but eventually including everyone’s, because everyone must someday die. So the Authority recreates himself in the image of his own lie, and turns everything else into something to be abjected.
Lyra, on the other hand, exists as a monster in liminal time. This is where the fact that she is an adolescent comes in. This stage of life, culturally, is considered “a time of transition from one state of being to another” marked by the “dissolution of boundaries” – and that’s exactly how Nuzum describes liminal monster time (Nuzum 210). There is a “lack of limits and rules” in liminal time, which makes people “vulnerable” to succumbing to transition into something new and monstrous (210). And if we think about the verbs associated with Eve – to Fall, to mother, and to disobey – these are not actions that adhere to that repetitive mythic time that “to authorize” does. The Authority can do that again and again and again, and recreate the same outcomes. But Eve’s actions – Lyra’s actions – cause irrevocable change, an end to one state of being and the beginning of another. So Lyra’s narrative role is to exist within that liminal moment of change and self-creation. Of course, the original Eve’s narrative ends in abjection, suffering, and blame. If Lyra is going to be a different Eve from the one in Genesis, she has to change the story.
LYRA SILVERTONGUE: MOVING THROUGH MEANINGS
Throughout The Golden Compass, Lyra’s primary goal is to rescue Roger before he is forced to undergo intercision. As Lyra races through the desolate North, she senses “the presence of the Dust, for the air seemed to be full of dark intentions, like the forms of thoughts not yet born” (Pullman Compass 390). This is another example of both heteroglossia – the myriad meanings of language – and liminal time. Everything is right on the cusp of changing and becoming. This includes Lyra herself. As an adolescent, with a still-changing dæmon, Lyra embodies unarticulated potentiality. Intention itself is liminal: it is desire not yet realized and action not yet taken. It exists between states of being, and it can manifest as anything.
Now, that is all very poetic, and I do truly love this section of The Golden Compass. Imagining the dark Arctic night teeming with intentions genuinely gives me chills. But my feelings about exactly how Pullman conceptualizes childhood and adolescence have evolved since doing my Master’s thesis over ten years ago. Namely, there is a glaring issue with the fact that Dust – the particle of consciousness – is something that children have almost none of until a physical turning point of puberty. Dust has created a symbiotic form with humanity, which I dig as a vision of multiple meanings and perspectives within a single person – our inherent expansiveness – and as a beautiful representation of the miracle of matter, all the star-stuff that improbably has to come together to comprise a thinking, feeling being. But based on the logic of this worldbuilding, children are literally incomplete humans. They are missing the most vital ingredient that makes them sapient. And then we get this very romanticized vision of adolescence as a state of becoming, which is certainly nicer than the negative stereotypes of adolescent self-discovery and exploration that Pullman wants to combat, but it does also reproduce a very culturally specific vision of what this stage of life is all about, and then it literally naturalizes and universalizes – or multiversalizes – that vision. None of this is very conducive to the way that I believe children and adolescents should be treated: as total, whole human beings with the full depth and breadth of situated, experience-informed knowledge that any other human has. A child’s knowledge and an adult’s are different, but that doesn’t mean there has to be a hierarchy. Yet Pullman’s worldbuilding entrenches just that. In a certain way, we can see here the distance that he himself describes between intention and action. His intentions were to empower young people like Lyra to resist too-strict boundaries and outdated adult narratives (particularly religious ones). Based on a lot of people’s responses to reading this series in their own childhoods, I think he did succeed in many ways. But Pullman is just as immersed in the soup of adultism as anyone else, and so he takes some of those boundaries and narratives for granted and reproduces them. He believes in young people’s heroism, but not necessarily their wholeness.
Sadly, Lyra is unable to save Roger. Her own father, Lord Asriel, severs Roger from his dæmon, not for religious reasons, but to harness the immense energy between body and soul to tear the boundaries between universes open. Cradling Roger’s corpse, Lyra is faced with “dry land in the sky” (Pullman Compass 393). At this threshold, Pantalaimon realizes that everything adults have ever told them has been some kind of a lie. Therefore, despite what the Church says, Dust “must be good” (397). Lyra and Pan cross the border between universes to learn the secrets of Dust, thereby disobeying the most unyielding rules of the Authority’s mythic, static culture in favor of unfettered knowledge in all its forms and perspectives.
The second novel of the trilogy, The Subtle Knife, introduces Will Parry, who lives in, essentially, our world. Modern technology, no dæmons, and at least no Calvinist pope, which, thank not-God, I guess. Will lives with his mentally ill mother and is scared that he will be separated from her if anyone discovers the extent of her illness, so he tries to protect her – which leads to his semi-inadvertent killing an intruder in their house. After securing his mother’s safety, he discovers and escapes through an open window between two universes (16). Unlike Lyra, Will is running away instead of running towards, so at first, he is more reactive than agentic. But you can guess from his name – Pullman sure loves a meaningful name – that he’s going to develop a will of his own. Contact with Lyra, the narrative embodiment of change, is necessary to complete his adolescent transformation as a boundary-breaker.
Will meets Lyra in the world of Cittagazze, in which consciousness-devouring “Specters” destroy the minds and will of adults by feeding on their Dust. Children and pre-settling adolescents are immune, once again demonstrating their ontological difference with “complete” grown-ups. Specters hail from the spaces between universes, and they enter through windows like the one Will found, which were created by the subtle knife of the title, a tool which can cut through the atomic bonds that separate and give shape to the uncountable universes. Will, again semi-inadvertently, fights the current knife-bearer and wins, thereby taking his place. Just like the role of Eve implies multiple actions, so too does the role of knife-bearer, as “to bear” is both to wield and to endure. The knife itself also has a verb-laden name: “Aesahaettr,” or god-destroyer (312). Perhaps the knife is not so subtle after all.
Will loses two fingers in the fight for the knife. In my Master’s thesis, I did a whole, fairly reluctant section about the Freudian implications of Will’s entire narrative arc, which I’m not going to get into very much today – though, like, tell me if you’re interested, I guess – but Pullman makes the symbolic castration here very blatant. This is significant in a couple ways, and it requires a bit of a tangent. So Pullman explicitly draws a connection between his fictional intercision and things like female genital mutilation in a way that I understand but kind of hate how he does it. He has an anti-Church adult character say that the latter real practice from various universes is “even worse” than the fictional intercision, and: don’t do that. Because, yes, physical alteration in the name of religion to control sexual expression and identity is a great evil. It does not, however, destroy the soul, or render its victims permanently incapable of full consciousness, which is what intercision does in the book. So in his overzealous effort to be on religiously abused children’s side, Pullman winds up dehumanizing them and treating them as irrevocably broken. Even more broadly, by linking the settling of Dust with specifically sexual knowledge, Pullman links sexuality and subjectivity in a way that should not really be universalized. Sexual self-knowledge is the most taboo and abject thing within the Church, and again, I get that Pullman is trying to demonstrate that punishing children for, like, going through puberty and learning about desire is bad, and obviously, co-signed. But by making this an immutable fact of nature and science, which is the ultimate and best and purest Truth, Pullman does, like Anne-Marie Bird argued, undercut his purported support for multiple meanings, because he lays out a very narrow way of being, especially sexually speaking, that would be aligned with true and complete personhood. But all of that is important to recognize when it comes to Will’s assumption of the knife-bearer role. It initially wounds him in a way that, within this text, is thinly-veiled sexualized and therefore inherent to his ability to make it through adolescence and get to a whole consciousness. But Lyra helps guide him there. As Will reels, Pantalaimon licks Will’s wounded hand, disregarding the profound taboo that prevents contact between a human and another person’s dæmon (182). Lyra and Will’s relationship is not yet romantic and sexual, but this certainly foreshadows that. It also demonstrates Lyra’s willingness to love the abject: the blood, the sexuality, the pain. She doesn’t throw these things away like the Authority does, but instead uses the seat of her empathy and her multiplicity – her external soul – to provide comfort to the violated. And that is exactly what she will continue to do as the new Eve.
At the beginning of The Amber Spyglass, Lyra has fallen back into her mother’s clutches. Mrs. Coulter has discovered, very much to her own surprise, that she actually loves Lyra, but that doesn’t mean she’s, like, deconstructed yet. She tries to prevent Lyra from acting, so she cannot become the monster of the Fall. To this end, Mrs. Coulter drugs Lyra into a fetal stasis and encloses her in a womb-like cave (Pullman Spyglass 5). But though physically incarcerated, Lyra’s consciousness cannot be confined. While she sleeps, she communes with Roger’s spirit. For these sections, Pullman plays with what Gérard Genette calls the paratextual conventions. “Paratexts” are “literary and printerly conventions that mediate between the world of publishing and the world of the text” (xvii), and they include, among other features, the book cover, title page, chapter breaks and headings, and epigraphs. So in The Amber Spyglass, Pullman plays with the novelistic form itself by inserting the conversation between Lyra and Roger in between chapters. The seven inter-chapter sections that do not have titles, headings, chapter numbers, or even page numbers (although they are silently tallied in the novel’s running page count). The more conventional chapters of the novel interrupt the sections of Lyra and Roger’s conversation mid-sentence, with their dialogue resuming once the chapter ends. In other words, Lyra is now so liminal and transgressive that the traditional structure of the novel can no longer contain her. In these textual margins, Roger comes to her surrounded by the dead, and when Lyra sees their “wide eyes and hopeless faces, pale faces, dark faces, young faces,” she resolves to save them (Pullman Spyglass 65). And here we get another meaning of her name: Lyra is the constellation of Orpheus’s lyre, which he took with him to the underworld.
After Will rescues Lyra from the cave (which involes another symbolic castration, this one extremely Oedipal, but I simply do not have the time or inclination, so moving on), they travel together to the world of the dead (Pullman Spyglass 246). Its inhabitants are the ultimate victims of the Authority’s narratives, in which death is both punishment and ending. Kristeva writes of the horror of cosmic and subjective stagnation in such a way that I have to wonder if her writing directly informed Pullman, because this is exactly what he is representing: “This is the horror of hell without God: if no means of salvation, no optimism, not even a humanistic one, looms on the horizon, then the verdict is in, with no hope of pardon—the sportful verdict of scription” (“Horror” 147). The dead are spirits without souls or bodies, parts of a whole. Like adolescents, they are unfinished and liminal, literally existing between worlds, as the land of the dead is an artificial space stuffed between naturally occurring universes. But unlike Lyra’s uncontainable adolescence, the dead are inert and easily confined, separated as they are from their dæmons, the conduits of Dust. (Again, I do think the spirits themselves are partially Dust, but Pullman’s worldbuilding gets a little wobbly here.) The important thing to note is that, though the Church has not yet figured out how to successfully halt the transition of adolescence, the Authority has utterly stalled the transformation inherent in death via his abjection of the dead. The shores of this land are littered with garbage, and the harpies who guard it are foul with rot. (This illustration is from Dante’s Inferno, another big influence here.) The world of the dead is where all the abject things go to fester for eternity away from the desperately unchanging subjectivity of the Authority.
But because the Authority could never control everything, it is impossible for a dæmon to go into the land of the dead; nature simply won’t allow it. So Lyra must separate from Pantalaimon, Pan – from mercy and from everything – to break the boundary between life and death (Pullman Spyglass 281). Though she longs to stay “true to the heart-deep, life-deep bond” she shares with her dæmon, she cannot put her own self above all other selves (281). In response, Pantalaimon switches forms to be “a creature so sunk in misery that it was more misery than creature,” embodying the despair of unnamable abjection (284). The narrative demands of the Fall of Man require Lyra, as Eve, to face expulsion and death as a consequence of her boundary-breaking. Monsters who transgress against hierarchical power always suffer.
But Lyra doesn’t try to run away from the inevitability of suffering like the Authority does. She adopts and experiences the pain of the dead, and allows them to inform and fuse with her own perspective, her own personhood. Lyra attempts to soothe the ghosts: “If my own dæmon was here, you could all stroke him and touch him” (Pullman Spyglass 296). If she could, she would allow these abject beings access to her own soul, though that is always meant to be separate and off-limits from anyone else. In lieu of lending them Pan, Lyra assumes a maternal role and physically comforts the dead children with her body, who flock to her for “warmth” (296). So Lyra unifies Eve’s seemingly disparate identities – as a mother and as a bearer of death – into a single narrative. Lyra does not cause death, but instead she rewrites the narrative of the verb “to die.” In the Authority’s story, dying means separation, abjection, containment. Lyra, however, reveals what will happen in her new death:
When you go out of here, all the particles that make you up will loosen and float apart, just like your dæmons did. … your dæmons en’t just nothing now; they’re part of everything. All the atoms that were them, they’ve gone into the air and the wind and the trees and the earth and all the living things. They’ll never vanish. They’re just part of everything. (Pullman Spyglass 319)
Unbeknownst to Lyra, she is narrating the end of the Fall of Man: “for dust thou art, and unto dust shalt thou return.” Instead of grand and opaque, Lyra’s narration is plain and honest in diction, tone, and style. In her rhetorically unsophisticated speech, the return to Dust is not a condemnation, but a promise of restoration. Lyra’s monstrous “destructiveness is really a deconstructiveness,” as Cohen deems it: “it threatens to reveal that difference originates in process, rather than in fact” (14-15). Lyra deconstructs past selves, making them both different from their original state but also fundamentally the same as the one who abjected them. They are all just matter and nature.
Lyra even embraces the hate-filled harpies and all of their disgusting abjection, as they are deeply moved by the plain truths that she shares with the dead. At first, she tries to charm them with lying – a habit of childhood that Pullman insists she must leave behind as she approaches adolescence and adulthood. Again, I don’t vibe with Pullman’s sharp dividing line between life stages here; he sort of naturalizes dishonesty in childhood as a consequence of lacking knowledge, which, boo. So the harpies attack Lyra when she lies, but they hunger for her truths. They are so abject that they don’t even have names, so they are literally without identity. Lyra does not cast them out for this wretchedness, but rather remakes them, granting the name of Gracious Wings to their leader. They help Lyra and Will lead the dead to a place where Will can cut through the boundaries of this in-between world to reconnect with the natural multiverse. So once a tool of destruction, the subtle knife becomes an instrument of creation. (And, yes, everything about that sentence is phallic.)
Will opens a window to “a canopy of dazzling stars, and the shine of water somewhere below, and here and there groves of great trees, as high as castles, dotting the wide savanna” (Pullman Spyglass 363). Roger is the first of the dead to escape the Authority’s boundaries and become part of “the night, the starlight, the air” (364). This passage recalls Kristeva’s description of the sublime: “When the starry sky, a vista of open seas or a stained glass window shedding purple beams fascinate me, there is a cluster of meaning, of colors, of words, of caresses, there are light touches, scents, sighs, cadences that arise, shroud me, carry me away, and sweep me beyond the things that I see, hear, or think” (Kristeva “Abjection” 12). Like the abject, the sublime is neither subject nor object, but while the abject is that which is removed, “the sublime is a something added that expands us” (12). Lyra transforms the abject to the sublime and erases the difference between the two. The dead add to nature’s “cluster of meanings.” Lyra, as Eve, brings all that was once cast out back into Eden.
LYRA, WILL, AND THE AUTHORITY: NARRATIVES COLLAPSED
Even after Lyra frees the dead, the Authority himself is still trapped within his endlessly looping mythic time. That first being of Dust now spends his days enclosed in a crystal litter, as a figure of “terrifying decrepitude” (Pullman Spyglass 396). The litter keeps his Dust from dissipating, but it cannot keep it functioning as a viable collective; that temporary consciousness failed a long time ago. Angels carry the litter and sing the hymns of the Authority’s narrative, ignoring his insensible cries of agony (396). He is literally trapped by his own exalted language. He has come to embody all that he fears about death: the corpse-like form, the lack of intention or agency. Monsters can never escape the abject. They are made of it.
After far too many lifetimes of punishing knowledge and change, the Authority is now trapped in a smaller space than any he devised for others. Yet Lyra’s mobility remains as unlimited as her empathy. When she comes face to face with the Authority, she does not know who and what he is. She is simply moved by his pain and calls him a “poor thing” (Pullman Spyglass 410). She asks Will to use the subtle knife to release the Authority from the litter (410). The Authority, likewise, does not know who Lyra is. He does not recognize her as the new Eve, the monster who has broken his boundaries and released the abjection he tried to contain. Instead, he looks at her with “innocent wonder.” And there’s the key word of our channel! Essentially, the Authority, stuck in his mythic time, has looped back around to a childlike state: innocent of his past crimes, but also incomplete and without access to the knowledge that is his literal atomic makeup. And also like the dead, he no longer has a “will of his own” (410). He cannot speak; he cannot narrate; he cannot authorize. I am torn, because I love the structural narrative payoff of this – this is such a literarily fitting fate for the Authority, and it really brings together all of Pullman’s themes. But also, since some of Pullman’s themes annoy me now, I do struggle with the conflation of childhood and old age, specifically like cognitively disabled old age, with incomplete personhood.
But I do love the way the Authority’s mythic narrative yields to Lyra’s liminal one as he disintegrates away from the crystal litter, “a mystery dissolving in mystery” (Pullman Spyglass 411). The subtle knife, the god-destroyer, has fulfilled its name, but not through violence: Will’s destruction and Lyra’s creation are now the same. Their narratives fuse as the Authority’s collapses. Lyra is truly the Mother of All and the Mother of Death. Her empathy for the abject destroys the boundaries between self and other, hinting at Cohen’s contention “that difference is arbitrary and potentially free-floating, mutable rather than essential” (12). The Authority depends on the difference between God and man, life and death, subject and abject. Lyra collapses these categories by empathizing with and incorporating all of them.
At the conclusion of The Amber Spyglass, Lyra and Will retreat to the world of the mulefa, conscious beings for whom nature and culture are in harmony. They spread a picnic, and Lyra holds a fruit to Will’s mouth, bringing her Fall narrative to its climax (Pullman Spyglass 465). They kiss, tentatively at first, then passionately, and Lyra declares her love for Will (466). We pull away from them then, but this is clearly a sexual encounter, and since Pullman links sexuality and self-knowledge, this is the moment where Dust finally “completes” these two adolescents: “The Dust pouring down from the stars had found a living home again, and these children-no-longer children, saturated with love, were the cause of it all” (470). Again, it’s beautiful, it’s sublime, it’s classic power of love stuff, and it wonderfully resists the cultural taboos around adolescent sexual self-discovery, which I think is really important. Increased sexual awareness and desire do frequently coincide with puberty, and the social constructions (very much including religious ones) that treat this time of life as inherently sinful because of that are obviously massively damaging to young people. I love that Pullman vehemently opposes those constructions with his narrative. My issue is with the “children-no-longer children.” At this point, Lyra and Will are still like thirteen and fourteen? So very much still children in many (including legal) senses, and I don’t think that either sexuality or knowledge should remove them from that category. So really, the issue I increasingly have is with the entire shape of the bildungsroman, the coming-of-age narrative, because it has this definitive finish line. Lyra and Will have now Come Of Age, TM. Not only does this framing do a disservice to children, as I explained earlier, by treating them as incomplete, but I think it also does a disservice to adults, because it treats them as finished people. And this does totally undercut Pullman’s larger theme of continuing to learn and change throughout one’s lifetime, which Lyra and Will commit to right after this. That is what keeps Dust flowing. So it’s just interesting how the coming-of-age narrative creates that sort of unresolvable thematic tension, but in a meta way, it almost loops back around to proving the same point, that everyone has inherited certain structures and assumptions and rules from their society, and it’s the work of a lifetime to identify and deconstruct them. That work still, at the time of him .writing this trilogy, was not done for Pullman himself. But we can take the conceptual basis of Dust from this story to imagine how we can keep doing that work. Bird argues that Dust “can never be the final explanation” because it represents “a shifting field of relations in which there is no secure and stable point” (197). This implies, however, that “the final explanation” must be fixed. Through reuniting death, life, and Dust, Lyra synthesizes universes of meaning without reducing them to univocality. Each conscious element has its own voice in a narrative whose heteroglossia makes it more, not less, true.
Yet even boundary-breaking monsters require a framework of meaning in which they can exist. For Lyra and Will, and for all of us, this framework is nature. When our narratives – like those of dominion or extraction – threaten nature, they must be changed, even if those changes are hard. Lyra and Will learn that they cannot live in each other’s universes, and they must close the portals made by the subtle knife to prevent new Specters from forming and Dust from “leaking out of the worlds and into nothingness” (Pullman Spyglass 484). If Lyra and Will teach people to “learn and understand about themselves and each other and the way everything works,” they can regenerate the Dust that was lost and leave one window open for the dead (492). But they themselves must live the rest of their lives apart. Lyra, in her plain speech, makes a vow of post-death reunion with Will:
…we’ll cling together so tight that nothing and no one’ll ever tear us apart. Every atom of me and every atom of you … We’ll live in birds and flowers and dragonflies and pine trees and in clouds and in those little specks of light you see floating in sunbeams … And when they use our atoms to make new lives, they won’t just be able to take one, they’ll have to take two, one of you and one of me, we’ll be joined so tight. (Pullman Spyglass 497)
Lyra and Will will one day become as indivisible as human and dæmon. As though to prove this point, Will (who, after traversing the world of the dead, now has his own external dæmon, and their dæmons have returned to them) – he makes the last great sexual and subjective connection with Lyra: “Knowing exactly what he was doing and exactly what it would mean, he moved his hand from Lyra’s wrist and stroked the red-gold fur of her dæmon” (Pullman Spyglass 498). Lyra responds in kind, forming an unbroken loop of interconnected subjectivity: “she knew… that neither dæmon would change now, having felt a lover’s hands on them” (499). Lyra and Will’s eventual return to Eden will be an explicitly multiplistic experience, in which they will be inextricably bound to each other across all of nature before integrating into uncountable new subjects. Lyra will narrate in her own voice and simultaneously in Will’s, and in the voices of all the future subjects whose narrative potential she has made possible by reversing the abjection of death and Dust.
CONCLUSION
When Lyra and Will return to their respective universes (he to the reader’s recognizably modern Oxford, and she to the Oxford of dæmons), Lyra is still a liminal figure who does not fit into any neat categories: “I’m not a bear and I’m not a witch … I don’t know what to do anymore. I’m lost, really, now” (Pullman Spyglass 514). Monstrosity is a lonely business. Yet Lyra has her dæmon and her connections to the consciousness surrounding her. After incorporating so many abject-subjectivities into her narrative, she resolves to build a new culture – “the Republic of Heaven” – in which she and others like her will not be considered monstrous (518). Kristeva argues that “from its place of banishment, the abject does not cease challenging its master” (“Abjection” 2). Through their transgressions, monsters create themselves out of the physical and biological materials and the political, cultural, and ideological discourses that their cultures refuse to authorize and therefore abject. In exposing the gaps in one system of meaning, the monster story alerts the reader to the possibility of multiple systems of meaning.
His Dark Materials is a celebration of liminality. Its most creative spaces are adolescence and death. Lyra’s heteroglossic narrative is Eve’s story, but also Will’s and Dust’s and the dead’s. Together, they Fall from the mythic loop of cultural hierarchy into an uncontained matrix of abject-subjectivity. For all its flaws, His Dark Materials portrays a protagonist who, through her empathy, presents an all-encompassing level of inclusion as a possibility for selfhood. The trilogy is a literary, cultural, and narrative monster in its own right, a hybrid of old tales and new twists, dangerous taboos and potential not yet realized. Its monster stories carry with them this threat and promise: whatever is abject now may yet become a subject.
I hope that you enjoyed this little trip into my literary analysis past, and its increasingly dramatic lighting, as a storm rolled in outside. If you did, please remember to give the video a like and a share. There is a ton more to talk about with His Dark Materials, so I may revisit this series in the future. Let me know if that is something you’d be interested in, and let me know your thoughts about these books in the comments. I find this series emotionally so moving, and also intellectually both fascinating and frustrating in equal measure, and that is a great recipe for analysis, as far as I’m concerned. So thank you for watching me work through it, and I will see you soon with more monstrous food for thought.
References:
- Bakhtin, Mikhail. “Discourse in the Novel.” The Dialogic Imagination: Four Essays. Trans. Caryl Emerson and Michael Holquist. Austin, TX: University of Texas Press, 1981, pp. 445-703. Google Play ed.
- Bird, Anne-Marie. “Circumventing the Grand Narrative: Dust as an Alternate Theological Vision in Pullman’s His Dark Materials.” His Dark Materials Illuminated: Critical Essays on Philip Pullman’s Trilogy. Ed. Millicent Lenz with Carole Scott. Landscapes of Childhood Series. Detroit: Wayne University Press, 2005.
- Cohen, Jeffrey Jerome. “Monster Culture (Seven Theses).” Monster Theory: Reading Culture. Ed. Jeffrey Jerome Cohen. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 1996, pp. 3-25.
- Genette, Gérard. Paratexts: Thresholds of Interpretation. Trans. Jane E. Lewin; foreword by Richard Macksey. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press: 1997.
- Kristeva, Julia. Powers of Horror: An Essay of Abjection. Trans. Leon S. Roudiez. New York: Columbia University Press, 1982.
- Nuzum, K.A. “The Monster’s Sacrifice – Historic Time: The Uses of Mythic and Liminal Time in Monster Literature.” Children’s Literature Association Quarterly 29.3 (2004): 207-227.